Can UN scientists revive drive against climate change?
A leaden cloak of responsibility lies on the shoulders of UN scientists as they put the final touches to the first volume of a massive report that will give the world the most detailed picture yet of climate change.
Due to be unveiled in Stockholm on September 27, the document will be scrutinised word by word by green groups, fossil-fuel lobbies and governments to see if it will yank climate change out of prolonged political limbo.
The report will kick off the fifth assessment by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), an expert body set up in 1988 to provide neutral advice on global warming and its impacts.
Six years ago, the IPCC's fourth assessment report unleashed a megawatt jolt of awareness. It declared that the planet was warming, that this was already starting to affect Earth's climate system and biosphere, and that there was overwhelming evidence that humans, especially by burning coal, gas and oil, were the cause.
It earned the IPCC a share in the Nobel Peace Prize with former US vice president Al Gore and stoked momentum that led to the 2009 climate conference in Copenhagen, the biggest summit in UN history.
Yet that was the high point. The near-fiasco of Copenhagen combined with a financial crisis that struck Western economies... and climate change vanished off politicians' radars. Then came damage to the IPCC's own reputation, when several errors were found in the landmark report, prompting a fightback by gleeful climate sceptics and a painful investigation of the panel itself.
A draft of the leviathan new work, seen by AFP, will amplify the 2007 warning in several ways.
The panel will declare it is even more confident that global warming is man-made and starting to affect extreme weather events, such as flooding, drought, heatwaves and wildfires. It also warns of a potential rise in sea levels that, by century's end, would drown many coastal cities in their current state of preparedness.
"Changes are projected to occur in all regions of the globe, and include changes in land and ocean, in the water cycle, in the cryosphere, in sea level, in some extreme events and in ocean acidification. Many of these changes would persist for centuries. Limiting climate change would require substantial and sustained reductions of CO2 [carbon dioxide] emissions," warns the draft.
The document, focussing on the science of climate change, will be followed next year by two volumes, on impacts and on how to tackle the problem, followed by a synthesis of all three texts.
The main text is written and approved by scientists, and cannot be modified by national governments, who also have representatives on the IPCC.
The governments do have a say, though, in the all-important summary for policymakers, which in its present form runs to 31 pages. So far, they have raised 1,800 reservations about the summary, and these will be hammered out in a line-by-line appraisal over four days before next month's release.
Defenders of the laborious system say approval by governments amounts to a "buy-in" from all the world's nations—a consensus ranging from huge carbon polluters China and the United States and vulnerable small-island states such as the Maldives to major oil and gas exporters like Qatar and Saudi Arabia.
"I am greatly in favour of this process of comments followed by adoption," Jean Jouzel, a leading French climate scientist who is vice president of the IPCC group in charge of the upcoming volume, told AFP. "The adoption is what gives the IPCC report its success and visibility, and enables its effective use by governments."
Others are not so sure. Inclusiveness, transparency and nitpicking mean the process is horribly slow.
Almost every week, new evidence of climate damage is published in peer-reviewed scientific journals. But the most recent scary stuff—the discovery, for instance, that melting permafrost is starting to leak methane, a potent greenhouse gas—will not be included in the new report because of the cutoff date for reviewing material.
"It [the summary] is a powerful document because it is signed off by all governments," said a source who follows the process closely. "But the IPCC has become such a conservative organisation. The report is really science at the lowest common denominator."
Michael Mann, a professor at Penn State University and author of a book, "The Hockey Stick and the Climate Wars," blames this in part on campaigning by well-funded sceptics who either deny global warming or pin it on natural causes, such as fluctuations in solar heat.
They intimidate individual scientists and exploit areas of scientific uncertainty to claim there is no expert consensus, he said. As a result, the IPCC compilers are driven to even greater caution, with the risk that they deliver a message that is fuzzy or larded with doubt.
"I believe that these pressures combine with the innate tendency of scientists to be reticent about drawing strong conclusions," said Mann.
As a result, "assessment reports like the IPCC report almost inevitably end up understating the conclusions and, in this case, the risks of human-caused climate change."
Explore further:Human activity is 'almost certainly' driving climate change, IPCC leaked report says
© 2013 AFP
More from Physics Forums - Earth
Related Stories
Human activity is 'almost certainly' driving climate change, IPCC leaked report says
Aug 21, 2013
Human activity is almost certainly the cause of climate change and global sea levels could rise by several feet by the end of the century, according to an Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) ...
Major climate change report draft leaked online: IPCC
Dec 14, 2012
A major report on climate change being compiled by the United Nation's climate science panel was on Friday leaked online in what appeared to be an attempt by a climate sceptic to discredit the panel.
UN climate panel denounces fresh data leaks (Update)
Jan 09, 2013
The UN's climate science panel bemoaned Wednesday a fresh leak of data from a landmark report on global warming that it will start releasing this year.
Solar forcing effect on climate change 'extremely small': IPCC scientist
Jan 15, 2013
Changes in solar radiation, known as solar forcing, have had only a very small effect on climate change, a member of the UN's top panel of climate scientists said today.
Climate change: drought benchmark is flawed, study says
Nov 14, 2012
A scientific method used in a landmark UN report that said warming was intensifying global drought is badly flawed, a study published on Wednesday said.
Australia heatwave part of global trend: IPCC chief
Jan 15, 2013
Australia's extreme summer heatwave, which caused devastating bushfires and saw temperature forecasts go off the scale, is part of a global warming trend, the UN's climate panel chief said Tuesday.
Recommended for you
California's Rim Fire doubles to 125,000 acres
1 hour ago
Firefighters in California struggled to contain a giant blaze threatening thousands of homes and sweeping into the famous Yosemite National Park.
Report: Puerto Rico unprepared for climate change
Aug 24, 2013
Environmental officials and scientists warned Friday that Puerto Rico is dangerously vulnerable to the effects of global climate change and urged it to prepare by better-regulated coastal development, and ...
Greenpeace ship defies Russia by entering Arctic route
Aug 24, 2013
Greenpeace said on Saturday it had defied the Russian authorities by sending its icebreaker through an Arctic shipping route to protest against oil drilling in the fragile ecosystem.
Can we save our urban water systems?
Aug 23, 2013
Existing urban water systems are at the end of their design lifetimes. New, innovative solutions are needed, and these must combine technology and engineering with an understanding of social systems and institutions. ...
3Qs: The current state of climate change science
Aug 23, 2013
Earlier this week, the public learned the details of the upcoming fifth assessment report (or, "AR5") of the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, an international body whose mandate ...
How fires spread: UK study brings new insight
Aug 23, 2013
University of Kentucky researchers are helping to gain insight into how fire spreads, knowledge that could help forestry officials develop more effective strategies for containing wildfires.
User comments : 1
Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank
Display comments: newest first
mememine69not rated yet14 minutes ago
What we need to do to save the planet from a CO2 disaster is to shut down the denial machine by insisting that science stops saying "maybe" and starts saying "will be" a crisis as what denier would deny an "inevitable crisis" instead of saying "possible crisis" for 28 years? Science has never agreed or said anything beyond "could be" a crisis.Unless CO2 mitigation starts soon we are doomed but denialism is preventing our children from having futures.
More news stories
California vies for new space industry
California is racing other states to woo new private companies planning to take people on trips to space.
California's Rim Fire doubles to 125,000 acres
Firefighters in California struggled to contain a giant blaze threatening thousands of homes and sweeping into the famous Yosemite National Park.
Human activity is 'almost certainly' driving climate change, IPCC leaked report says
Human activity is almost certainly the cause of climate change and global sea levels could rise by several feet by the end of the century, according to an Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) ...
Astronomers use Hubble images for movies featuring space slinky
(Phys.org) —Astronomers have assembled, from more than 13 years of observations from NASA's Hubble Space Telescope, a series of time-lapse movies showing a jet of superheated gas—5,000 light-years long—as ...
Arctic sea ice update: Unlikely to break records, but continuing downward trend (w/ Video)
The melting of sea ice in the Arctic is well on its way toward its annual "minimum," that time when the floating ice cap covers less of the Arctic Ocean than at any other period during the year. While the ice will continue ...
DC panda that birthed live cub has stillborn one too
An official says a panda that gave birth to a cub at Washington's National Zoo has also given birth to a stillborn cub.
One million cockroaches flee China farm: report
At least one million cockroaches have escaped a farm in China where they were being bred for use in traditional medicine, a report said.
How to help kids quell back-to-school jitters
(HealthDay)—Some children feel anxious about going back to school, but parents can help ease their fears, experts say.
Expert tips for school bus safety
(HealthDay)—Many children are injured each year just getting on and off the school bus. Inattentive drivers, horseplay, unsafe street crossing and even clothing issues can all contribute.
Wet noses to the touchscreen, iPads go to the dogs
You may or may not be able to teach an old dog new tricks, but you can certainly try to get Fido to use an iPad.
© Phys.org™ 2003-2013
A leaden cloak of responsibility lies on the shoulders of UN scientists as they put the final touches to the first volume of a massive report that will give the world the most detailed picture yet of climate change.
Due to be unveiled in Stockholm on September 27, the document will be scrutinised word by word by green groups, fossil-fuel lobbies and governments to see if it will yank climate change out of prolonged political limbo.
The report will kick off the fifth assessment by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), an expert body set up in 1988 to provide neutral advice on global warming and its impacts.
Six years ago, the IPCC's fourth assessment report unleashed a megawatt jolt of awareness. It declared that the planet was warming, that this was already starting to affect Earth's climate system and biosphere, and that there was overwhelming evidence that humans, especially by burning coal, gas and oil, were the cause.
It earned the IPCC a share in the Nobel Peace Prize with former US vice president Al Gore and stoked momentum that led to the 2009 climate conference in Copenhagen, the biggest summit in UN history.
Yet that was the high point. The near-fiasco of Copenhagen combined with a financial crisis that struck Western economies... and climate change vanished off politicians' radars. Then came damage to the IPCC's own reputation, when several errors were found in the landmark report, prompting a fightback by gleeful climate sceptics and a painful investigation of the panel itself.
A draft of the leviathan new work, seen by AFP, will amplify the 2007 warning in several ways.
The panel will declare it is even more confident that global warming is man-made and starting to affect extreme weather events, such as flooding, drought, heatwaves and wildfires. It also warns of a potential rise in sea levels that, by century's end, would drown many coastal cities in their current state of preparedness.
"Changes are projected to occur in all regions of the globe, and include changes in land and ocean, in the water cycle, in the cryosphere, in sea level, in some extreme events and in ocean acidification. Many of these changes would persist for centuries. Limiting climate change would require substantial and sustained reductions of CO2 [carbon dioxide] emissions," warns the draft.
The document, focussing on the science of climate change, will be followed next year by two volumes, on impacts and on how to tackle the problem, followed by a synthesis of all three texts.
The main text is written and approved by scientists, and cannot be modified by national governments, who also have representatives on the IPCC.
The governments do have a say, though, in the all-important summary for policymakers, which in its present form runs to 31 pages. So far, they have raised 1,800 reservations about the summary, and these will be hammered out in a line-by-line appraisal over four days before next month's release.
Defenders of the laborious system say approval by governments amounts to a "buy-in" from all the world's nations—a consensus ranging from huge carbon polluters China and the United States and vulnerable small-island states such as the Maldives to major oil and gas exporters like Qatar and Saudi Arabia.
"I am greatly in favour of this process of comments followed by adoption," Jean Jouzel, a leading French climate scientist who is vice president of the IPCC group in charge of the upcoming volume, told AFP. "The adoption is what gives the IPCC report its success and visibility, and enables its effective use by governments."
Others are not so sure. Inclusiveness, transparency and nitpicking mean the process is horribly slow.
Almost every week, new evidence of climate damage is published in peer-reviewed scientific journals. But the most recent scary stuff—the discovery, for instance, that melting permafrost is starting to leak methane, a potent greenhouse gas—will not be included in the new report because of the cutoff date for reviewing material.
"It [the summary] is a powerful document because it is signed off by all governments," said a source who follows the process closely. "But the IPCC has become such a conservative organisation. The report is really science at the lowest common denominator."
Michael Mann, a professor at Penn State University and author of a book, "The Hockey Stick and the Climate Wars," blames this in part on campaigning by well-funded sceptics who either deny global warming or pin it on natural causes, such as fluctuations in solar heat.
They intimidate individual scientists and exploit areas of scientific uncertainty to claim there is no expert consensus, he said. As a result, the IPCC compilers are driven to even greater caution, with the risk that they deliver a message that is fuzzy or larded with doubt.
"I believe that these pressures combine with the innate tendency of scientists to be reticent about drawing strong conclusions," said Mann.
As a result, "assessment reports like the IPCC report almost inevitably end up understating the conclusions and, in this case, the risks of human-caused climate change."
Explore further:Human activity is 'almost certainly' driving climate change, IPCC leaked report says
© 2013 AFP
More from Physics Forums - Earth
Related Stories
Human activity is 'almost certainly' driving climate change, IPCC leaked report says
Aug 21, 2013
Human activity is almost certainly the cause of climate change and global sea levels could rise by several feet by the end of the century, according to an Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) ...
Major climate change report draft leaked online: IPCC
Dec 14, 2012
A major report on climate change being compiled by the United Nation's climate science panel was on Friday leaked online in what appeared to be an attempt by a climate sceptic to discredit the panel.
UN climate panel denounces fresh data leaks (Update)
Jan 09, 2013
The UN's climate science panel bemoaned Wednesday a fresh leak of data from a landmark report on global warming that it will start releasing this year.
Solar forcing effect on climate change 'extremely small': IPCC scientist
Jan 15, 2013
Changes in solar radiation, known as solar forcing, have had only a very small effect on climate change, a member of the UN's top panel of climate scientists said today.
Climate change: drought benchmark is flawed, study says
Nov 14, 2012
A scientific method used in a landmark UN report that said warming was intensifying global drought is badly flawed, a study published on Wednesday said.
Australia heatwave part of global trend: IPCC chief
Jan 15, 2013
Australia's extreme summer heatwave, which caused devastating bushfires and saw temperature forecasts go off the scale, is part of a global warming trend, the UN's climate panel chief said Tuesday.
Recommended for you
California's Rim Fire doubles to 125,000 acres
1 hour ago
Firefighters in California struggled to contain a giant blaze threatening thousands of homes and sweeping into the famous Yosemite National Park.
Report: Puerto Rico unprepared for climate change
Aug 24, 2013
Environmental officials and scientists warned Friday that Puerto Rico is dangerously vulnerable to the effects of global climate change and urged it to prepare by better-regulated coastal development, and ...
Greenpeace ship defies Russia by entering Arctic route
Aug 24, 2013
Greenpeace said on Saturday it had defied the Russian authorities by sending its icebreaker through an Arctic shipping route to protest against oil drilling in the fragile ecosystem.
Can we save our urban water systems?
Aug 23, 2013
Existing urban water systems are at the end of their design lifetimes. New, innovative solutions are needed, and these must combine technology and engineering with an understanding of social systems and institutions. ...
3Qs: The current state of climate change science
Aug 23, 2013
Earlier this week, the public learned the details of the upcoming fifth assessment report (or, "AR5") of the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, an international body whose mandate ...
How fires spread: UK study brings new insight
Aug 23, 2013
University of Kentucky researchers are helping to gain insight into how fire spreads, knowledge that could help forestry officials develop more effective strategies for containing wildfires.
User comments : 1
Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank
Display comments: newest first
mememine69not rated yet14 minutes ago
What we need to do to save the planet from a CO2 disaster is to shut down the denial machine by insisting that science stops saying "maybe" and starts saying "will be" a crisis as what denier would deny an "inevitable crisis" instead of saying "possible crisis" for 28 years? Science has never agreed or said anything beyond "could be" a crisis.Unless CO2 mitigation starts soon we are doomed but denialism is preventing our children from having futures.
More news stories
California vies for new space industry
California is racing other states to woo new private companies planning to take people on trips to space.
California's Rim Fire doubles to 125,000 acres
Firefighters in California struggled to contain a giant blaze threatening thousands of homes and sweeping into the famous Yosemite National Park.
Human activity is 'almost certainly' driving climate change, IPCC leaked report says
Human activity is almost certainly the cause of climate change and global sea levels could rise by several feet by the end of the century, according to an Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) ...
Astronomers use Hubble images for movies featuring space slinky
(Phys.org) —Astronomers have assembled, from more than 13 years of observations from NASA's Hubble Space Telescope, a series of time-lapse movies showing a jet of superheated gas—5,000 light-years long—as ...
Arctic sea ice update: Unlikely to break records, but continuing downward trend (w/ Video)
The melting of sea ice in the Arctic is well on its way toward its annual "minimum," that time when the floating ice cap covers less of the Arctic Ocean than at any other period during the year. While the ice will continue ...
DC panda that birthed live cub has stillborn one too
An official says a panda that gave birth to a cub at Washington's National Zoo has also given birth to a stillborn cub.
One million cockroaches flee China farm: report
At least one million cockroaches have escaped a farm in China where they were being bred for use in traditional medicine, a report said.
How to help kids quell back-to-school jitters
(HealthDay)—Some children feel anxious about going back to school, but parents can help ease their fears, experts say.
Expert tips for school bus safety
(HealthDay)—Many children are injured each year just getting on and off the school bus. Inattentive drivers, horseplay, unsafe street crossing and even clothing issues can all contribute.
Wet noses to the touchscreen, iPads go to the dogs
You may or may not be able to teach an old dog new tricks, but you can certainly try to get Fido to use an iPad.
© Phys.org™ 2003-2013