[Jonathan H. Adler] An “ugly, illiberal footnote” to a “happy, hopeful story.”

Conor Friedersdorf on the forced resignation of Mozilla CEO Brendan Eich for having donated $1,000 to support California’s anti-same-sex marriage Proposition 8 six years ago and refusing to apologize for it.

Calls for his ouster were premised on the notion that all support for Proposition 8 was hateful, and that a CEO should be judged not just by his or her conduct in the professional realm, but also by political causes he or she supports as a private citizen.

If that attitude spreads, it will damage our society. . . .

It isn’t difficult to see the wisdom in inculcating the norm that the political and the professional are separate realms, for following it makes so many people and institutions better off in a diverse, pluralistic society. The contrary approach would certainly have a chilling effect on political speech and civic participation, as does Mozilla’s behavior toward Eich. . . .

Mozilla says, “While painful, the events of the last week show exactly why we need the web. So all of us can engage freely in the tough conversations we need to make the world better.” Again, Mozilla’s actions will undercut tough conversations by making fewer people willing to engage in them. If you believe that an open, robust public discourse makes the world better, as they purport to, they’ve made the world worse. This action is a betrayal of their values, not a reflection of them.

At least that’s what this Mozilla user and fervent gay-marriage proponent believes.

Go read the whole thing.

Additional thoughts on the campaign to oust Eich fromJonathan Rauch(“intolerant and obnoxious”) andAndrew Sullivan(“the whole episode disgusts me”).

Also on The Volokh Conspiracy

Federal judge to force Ohio to recognize out-of-state same-sex marriages